The Turkey Problem:
What My First Holiday Bonus Taught Me About Employee Rewards
Right after college, I landed my first role as a housekeeping supervisor. It was a great job. The team was supportive, the work was hard, yet rewarding, and the company offered solid benefits. Every Thanksgiving, they gave each of us a turkey as a holiday bonus.
I was 22 and living in the city. I remember standing there with a 12-pound turkey in my arms, wondering how I was supposed to get it home on the bus. Once I solved that problem, a bigger one showed up. I didn't cook. I didn't own a roasting pan, let alone an oven big enough to fit it, a meat thermometer, a baster, or any of the other tools a turkey seems to require. I would have to buy all of it, and then I would have to figure out how to cook the thing.
I was grateful. The company meant well, and the gesture came from a good place. Someone in leadership wanted to say thank you at a meaningful time of year, and a turkey is a classic way to do that.
It just wasn’t right for me.
A Gift Can Be Generous and Still Miss
Employees at that company could pass their turkey along to a coworker or donate it to a local food bank, and plenty of people did. That was a nice option, and I appreciate that someone thought to build it in. But think about what it meant for me. I received a bonus, and the best use of it was to give it away. For a 22-year-old on a supervisor's salary, a gift card to the grocery store would have meant a lot. So would a choice between a turkey, a gift card, or an extra few dollars in my paycheck.
I wasn't the only one. I can think of vegetarian coworkers, coworkers who were traveling for the holiday, coworkers who were cooking for twenty people, and coworkers who were cooking for no one. A few people were thrilled. Some were mildly inconvenienced. Others quietly handed theirs off in the break room and never mentioned it.
That was my first lesson in employee rewards. Bonuses aren’t one-size-fits-all. A well-intended perk can miss the mark entirely when we haven't taken the time to learn what people value.
The Cost of Guessing
The company spent a lot of money on those turkeys. Budget, time, and thought went into that program. And the return on that spending was uneven, because the reward was built around what leadership assumed would be appreciated rather than around what employees would use.
This happens all the time, and it happens in organizations of every size. A few examples I've seen over the years:
• A pizza party for a team with a lot of parents, who would have preferred leaving an hour early to be home for dinner.
• A company-branded jacket for employees who work indoors in a warm climate.
• A wellness stipend that only covers gym memberships, offered to a team that would rather spend it on childcare or a therapist.
• A recognition event held at 6:00 pm for staff who have second jobs or caregiving responsibilities.
Each of these rewards could be meaningful to different employees. The challenge comes when leadership chooses rewards based on what they think employees will appreciate and doesn’t consider the different needs and preferences of their team. Employees come from different backgrounds, income levels, family situations, and stages of life. A recent graduate on a tight budget and a mid-career manager with three kids may have very different ideas about what makes a valuable reward.
The cost of the reward could go beyond the dollars spent. Employees notice when a gesture isn't quite right. Some will quietly conclude that leadership doesn't know them well. That's a hard impression to undo and it can undercut the goodwill you were trying to build in the first place.
When in Doubt, Ask
The fix is simple: ask employees what they value.
Asking is one of the most effective tools we have in HR and leadership. Before you launch a new bonus, redesign your benefits, or plan the next appreciation event, find out what would be meaningful to the employees. You don't need an elaborate process.
A few options:
Run a short survey. Five or six questions is plenty. Ask employees to rank a handful of possible rewards or to pick their top two from a list. Include an open-ended question at the end, because those answers can be the most helpful.
Talk to people directly. Managers who have regular one-on-ones can ask, "When you think about recognition, what feels right?" Some people want a public shout-out. Others would be mortified by one and would rather get a handwritten note or a day off.
Form a small employee committee. A group of five or six people from different departments, roles, and tenures can give you a much more accurate read than leadership can alone. Include someone from the front line. In my housekeeping days, the people doing the work every day knew exactly what would have helped them, yet nobody ever asked.
Offer choices when you can. Choice is one of the easiest ways to make a reward fit. A menu of options, such as a gift card, a turkey, a paid hour off, or a donation made in their name, lets each person pick what works for them. It might cost the same as the original plan, though the felt value is far greater.
Choice Doesn't Have to Be Complicated
I hear a common objection, especially from managers with lean teams. It goes something like this: "We don't have time to manage a menu of options for every person." I understand the concern, and I used to be that person. Until I sat down one day and asked the employees what they thought. Turns out, that was the easier route to take.
The goal is to keep the effort manageable while giving people a little room to make the reward their own. Even a small amount of flexibility signals something valuable, which is that you see your employees as individuals.
You know your team better than others. You notice when one person is saving for a house and another is planning a wedding. You can tell who loves a long weekend and who would rather have the cash. A well-timed, well-fitted reward from a small team often has more weight than a large program from the company.
Programs That Hold Value for Everyone
These programs should hold value for the employee. A well-thought-out program also adds value to the company.
When employees feel appreciated in a way that fits their lives, they tend to stay longer, engage more, and speak well of their workplace. That helps with retention, recruiting, and morale, which every employer cares about. A reward that misses the mark costs the same money and returns very little.
So before your next holiday bonus, appreciation week, or benefits renewal, ask a few questions:
1. What do we want this reward to accomplish?
2. Who is receiving it, and what do we know about their lives?
3. Have we asked them what they would find valuable?
4. Is there a way to build in some choice?
Check in once the reward has been given. A quick follow-up tells you what to repeat and what to change next year.
The Turkey
I never cooked that turkey. I gave it to a coworker who was hosting a big family dinner and she was delighted. In the end, it found a good home. I think about that often, because the turkey itself was never the problem. It simply went to the wrong person.
A thoughtful gift in the wrong hands is a missed opportunity, and it's easy to avoid. A short conversation, a quick survey, or an option to choose can turn a nice gesture into one that people remember.
This Thanksgiving season, if you're planning something for your team, take a moment to ask them what they would like. They'll tell you. And it might be something you never would have guessed.
If you'd like help figuring out what your employees value and building a rewards or benefits program around it, I'd be glad to talk it through. Reach out any time.
I am not an attorney and I do not offer legal advice. These tips are based on HR best practices. The people in these stories are not real and any likeness to anyone is pure coincidence.